Date of Conferral

10-28-2026

Date of Award

October 2026

Degree

Ph.D.

School

Education

Advisor

Celeste Fenton

Abstract

A southern state offers online and face-to-face instruction for students in Grades 3 and 7. The problem addressed in this quantitative study was the gap in research comparing school-level mathematics performance between online and face-to-face schools serving Grades 3 and 7 in a southern state. Grounded in connectivism, the purpose of this study was to investigate whether there is a difference in average school-level mathematics standards of learning (SOL) scaled scores between schools providing online instruction and schools providing face-to-face instruction. Independent-samples t tests were used to analyze publicly available mathematics SOL scores across 3 consecutive school years. The Grade 3 sample included 430 school-year observations from eight online and 139 face-to-face schools. The Grade 7 sample included 117 observations from seven online and 46 face-to-face schools. Face-to-face schools were selected from the same school divisions as the online schools. Grade 3 results indicate significantly higher average scores for face-to-face schools, with a mean difference of 44.44 points, p < .001, and a large effect size (Cohen’s d = −1.23). Grade 7 results showed no statistically significant difference, p = .528, with a small effect size (Cohen’s d = −0.18). Robustness and sensitivity analyses supported these findings. Future research could incorporate student-level data and demographic predictors. The findings may contribute to positive social change by helping educators identify targeted instructional supports, allocate resources to address students’ academic needs, and guide families in making informed decisions about online and face-to-face learning, which might benefit student learning.

Included in

Education Commons

Share

 
COinS